You can expect classic small plates like paella and croquetas, but the craft cocktails are where the party gets started. 173 Best Birthdays Restaurants In Theater District / Times Square | OpenTable Home United States New York / Tri-State Area Best Birthdays Restaurants in Theater District / Times Square May 1, 2023 7:00 PM 2 people Find a table 173 restaurants available nearby 1. Enjoy classic dishes like tacos and enchiladas, as well as creative cocktails. Please enter a valid email and try again. Enjoy dishes like poached lobster and foie gras terrine in the sophisticated atmosphere. Gramercy Tavern is a popular American restaurant near Union Square. The Hottest New Restaurants in Nashville, November 2022, Quarters are tight at Harts but thats precisely what helps make this restaurant one of the sexiest date spots around. Enjoy dishes like beef tartare and cote de boeuf, as well as creative cocktails. Best Fun Restaurants for Kids' Birthdays in NYC - Mommy Poppins Claud Also featured in: The 15 Hottest New Restaurants in Manhattan, April 2023 10 Places to Dine Outside in. Most allow you to book space for up to six. Carroll Gardens Perfect For: Casual Weeknight Dinner $$$$ 407 Smith St, Brooklyn View Website Earn 3X Points Like Hwa Yuan, Ugly Baby in Carroll Gardens is geared towards group celebrations. Sea Fire Grill is a great spot for seafood lovers. This pizzeria is a sure-fire hit, and your friends will love it. But the good news is that there are still restaurants where you can celebrate with a few friends, ex-parental guardians, or a fun combination of the two. Overall its a great choice for the best birthday restaurants in NYC, just be sure to book ahead as its very popular. Daily-changing specials offer something new to find with each visit making it a date spot to keep on regular rotation that never gets old while smushed up against some of Brooklyns hippest couples. This award-winning restaurant offers an eclectic menu of seasonal dishes. Oops.